Lodge + Dine announces a 5-star rating for 1 Hotel Hanalei Bay after a three day’s visit evaluating the guest experience. The hotel stood out for its sweeping views of Hanalei Bay, the refined comfort of its rooms and suites, and the seamless integration of Kauaʻi’s natural landscape throughout the property.
Situated in Princeville overlooking Hanalei Bay, 1 Hotel Hanalei Bay commands some of the island’s most remarkable views—complete with rainbows that appear almost daily. The air feels charged with salt and flora, while the initial greeting reflects an effort to blend hospitality with the island’s natural rhythms. Guests are drawn into the environment as much as into the property itself, with Hanalei Bay unfolding like a living mural in front of them.
Design is central to the experience, and here it communicates values as much as aesthetics. The lobby and shared spaces are understated, prioritizing open sightlines and natural materials that direct attention outward rather than inward. It avoids the excesses of conventional luxury, instead rooting guests in a calming atmosphere that feels both modern and tied to the cultural fabric of Kauaʻi. This balance between restraint and refinement creates a first impression that lingers.
Accommodations continue the theme of sanctuary. Rooms are styled to maximize ocean views, with layouts that emphasize space and comfort. Families find flexibility in connecting suites, while signature suites with private terraces invite couples to retreat in quiet privacy. For those seeking a grander option, the Makana Penthouse merges multiple living areas with panoramic views, making it well-suited for extended gatherings. Mornings are defined by the glow of sunrise over the bay, evenings by the sound of waves carrying through open windows.
Beyond the rooms, on-site experiences expand the scope of the stay. Six restaurants provide a strong sense of culinary variety, each drawing from local inspiration. Wellness offerings are among the most distinctive, blending traditional Hawaiian healing practices with advanced therapies like meditation pods and hyperbaric oxygen treatment. The fitness center, at 10,000 square feet, caters to those with rigorous routines, while guided hikes and cultural activities such as hula lessons or lei making connect guests to the land and traditions. Poolside leisure rounds out the options—an adult infinity pool for quiet reflection, a family pool for lively afternoons, and shaded cabanas that make beachside relaxation effortless.
Service plays a defining role in sustaining the five-star standard. Staff members offer more than efficiency; they extend cultural knowledge and personal touches that foster a sense of belonging. Whether through itinerary planning, casual conversation, or small gestures of attentiveness, the team demonstrates a commitment to ensuring every guest feels included, or as locals would say, ʻohana.
Not everything reached perfection. Housekeeping proved inconsistent, sometimes arriving late in the day or not at all, while some towels and beach sheets showed signs of wear with stains or tears. Elevators on the lower floors, lacking air conditioning, grew uncomfortably hot, and the public nature of the beachfront meant that outside visitors often set up near the hotel’s loungers. Yet these issues, though noticeable, did not ultimately diminish the overall impression of the stay.
Taken as a whole, this establishment offers an experience that resonates well beyond the typical luxury hotel. It is a place where natural beauty and thoughtful design converge, where service feels personal, and where both relaxation and activity find equal footing. Couples, families, and wellness seekers alike will leave with the memory of rainbows over the bay and the rare sense that five stars here signify not just luxury, but a genuine connection to place.
Kauaʻi Series: Plant-Forward and Hyperlocal Cuisine, The Flavors of Kaua‘i Elevated at 1 Kitchen
Kauaʻi Series: The Bistro’s Plantation-Style Setting, Casual Fare with Room to Grow
Kauaʻi Series: Welina Terrace, Where Japanese Flavors Meet Kaua‘i’s Iconic Peaks
Kauaʻi Series: Savor Authentic Ramen and Noodles in Kauai’s Tropical Setting at AMA Restaurant