Lodge + Dine announces a 4-star rating for Cittanuova after a day’s visit evaluating the guest experience. The restaurant impressed particularly with its prime East Hampton location, vibrant lunchtime atmosphere, and refined Italian fare.
Uniting European sophistication with Hamptons casual cool, Cittanuova is a chic Milanese-style trattoria in the heart of East Hampton. The atmosphere is friendly and fashionable, offering a comfortable space where guests can enjoy contemporary Italian cuisine in a bright, lively setting. It’s a welcoming spot where the blend of stylish design and laid-back energy makes every visit feel effortless yet refined.
During the day, the space feels airy and sunlit, with natural light streaming through to illuminate sleek tables and modern details. Touches of greenery soften the scene, while the gentle movement of Main Street adds a sense of rhythm to the experience. The result is a setting that feels both elegant and easygoing—perfect for unhurried lunches and good company.
The menu reflects the heart of Italian dining: simple, flavorful dishes prepared with care and quality ingredients. Starters like Polpette della Nonna—grandma’s meatballs baked in marinara and topped with grana padano set a nostalgic yet elevated tone. For a lighter beginning, the Zuppa Minestrone brings the freshness of garden vegetables simmered in a herbaceous broth. Among the salads, the Cesare stands out with crisp romaine, radicchio, and a house-made dressing that strikes the right balance between tang and creaminess.
The Rigatoni alla Vodka offers a satisfying depth of flavor, with shrimp, Calabrian chilies, and roasted tomatoes lending a gentle heat and sweetness, while basil and pecorino round out the dish’s richness. On the pizza front, diners can choose between red and white varieties—the Salsiccia with fennel sausage and San Marzano tomato sauce is hearty and aromatic, while the Quattro Formaggi in creamy besciamella showcases the luxurious melt of four cheeses. For mains, the Salmone Verde delivers a standout balance of textures, pairing pan-seared salmon with roasted artichoke hearts and chimichurri for a bright finish.
The bar program leans into easy elegance. The Aperol Spritz reigns supreme, a sparkling blend of Prosecco, Aperol, and soda that’s light, citrusy, and just bittersweet enough to refresh the palate between bites. Those seeking a non-alcoholic option can enjoy Badger Sparkling Bottles in flavors like Pink Grapefruit or Ginger Beer, each crisp and lively enough to complement the meal.
Service here aligns perfectly with the setting, attentive yet relaxed. Staff are pleasant and well-informed, moving with an ease that reflects both professionalism and genuine warmth. Whether you’re a solo diner catching a break from shopping or a group enjoying a leisurely midday meal, the overall experience feels thoughtfully curated.
Cittanuova thrives on its ability to make a casual lunch feel a little bit special. With its European sensibility, approachable Italian dishes, and open-air ambiance, this establishment brings a taste of Milanese charm to East Hampton’s vibrant core, proof that sophistication can live comfortably in the daylight.
Amagansett, New York Series: A Gentle Escape by the Atlantic, The Roundtree’s Quiet Appeal