Lodge + Dine announces a 3-star rating for Binchotan Bar & Grill after a day’s visit evaluating the guest experience. The restaurant delivered most notably in its Asian-inspired cuisine, yet the overall experience still calls for greater attention.
At first glance, Binchotan Bar & Grill carries an inviting promise: a modern open-air concept where Asian flavors meet Hawaiian warmth. The idea is compelling—an atmosphere that blends the soul of the islands with inventive takes on grilled fare and shared plates. The concept hints at a vibrant dining experience, yet the execution reveals room for refinement.
As evening set in, the scene was undeniably picturesque. Guests were treated to a sunset horizon streaked with purples and oranges, framed by swaying palms. Tables surrounded a fire feature, with patterned cushions adding a splash of personality. Yet beneath the beauty of the backdrop, the energy in the space felt subdued. The lighting, while warm, seemed to highlight an atmosphere that lacked the lively hum one expects from a gathering place.
Culinary offerings showcase a commitment to fire-grilled techniques and fresh, local ingredients. Starters like the Crispy Bao Buns filled with tender chashu pork delivered on texture—pillowy softness meeting savory richness. Charred Shishito Peppers offered a pleasant kick balanced by pickled ginger aioli, a nod to the kitchen’s playful side. The Big Island Roll, with shrimp tempura, ono, and avocado, arrived crisp and well-constructed, each bite lifted by furikake crunch and pepper aioli. Among entrées, the Crispy Whole Snapper stood out visually, its golden exterior paired with a bright Thai herb salad. Dessert, however, provided the most satisfying note: a Brûléed Japanese Cheesecake with silky depth, elevated by Kona coffee ice cream.
The bar program leans toward classic pairings, with red, white, rosé, and sparkling selections complementing the food. Cocktails are curated with a light tropical touch—refreshing but not overly adventurous. While the drinks align with the menu, they could benefit from more daring profiles to echo the boldness promised in the culinary concept.
Service was a mixed experience. Staff were pleasant and approachable, yet the attentiveness fell short of what one expects in a setting aiming for upscale dining. Small details, from timing to table upkeep, made the experience feel more ordinary than polished. Combined with facilities that could have been tidier, the evening left an impression of missed opportunities.
This establishment is best suited for those seeking a scenic backdrop more than an animated night out. With its open-air design and promise of Asian-inspired flavors fused with island soul, the foundation is strong. Yet with sharper service, livelier energy, and greater consistency, the restaurant has the potential to rise well beyond its current three-star standing.
Big Island Series: Experience Hawaiian Escape of Oceanfront Bliss at Mauna Lani, Auberge Resorts
Big Island Series: Indulge in Coastal Mediterranean Flavors with Pacific Flair at HāLani
Big Island Series: Experience Japanese-Inspired Cuisine Beneath the Palms at Canoe House
Big Island Series: Paniolo-Inspired Dining in Motion, The Open Kitchen Experience at Kona Village